DPU

Aarhus University Seal

Project description

Supermarket work and retail as a professional field


Viewing supermarkets and retail as a professional field, united by a shared task carried out in many different ways, provides the framework for the project ‘The supermarket – people, culture, past and future’. Everything we study in the present draws on a historical perspective to some extent, because history influences how things take shape today. We also explore ideas about the future, with new technological solutions, new groups of employees and new customer demands already on the horizon.

Read more about supermarkets and retail as a professional field

Like other professional fields, retail constitutes a distinct field of practice.

Traditional professions such as medicine and law are closely connected to the state and have acquired privileges partly through this relationship. Newer professional fields, such as architecture and engineering, work with specific subject matter and methods, often across disciplinary boundaries. Retail can likewise be viewed as a distinct professional field, concerned with activities (buying and selling goods) within its own organisational setting.

The field encompasses many different roles, from the youngest shop assistant to the person responsible for an entire chain. Specialist roles cut across these, both within individual shops and in support functions dealing with areas such as distribution and marketing. Yet the field also has a shared task: supplying and selling goods to meet ordinary customers’ everyday needs.

Employees are a central part of the retail sector. Historically, they were self-taught or trained within the family; today, trained retail staff and assistants make up most of the workforce. Many others also move in and out of the sector: school pupils, students taking a gap year, and people who previously worked in entirely different industries. Today, growing numbers of employees have higher education qualifications, particularly in support functions dealing with planning, buying, marketing and HR.

Different parts of the sector approach buying and selling goods in different ways: from the somewhat impersonal but efficient discount shop to the local grocer who knows most customers personally, and from the supermarket with its carefully selected product range to the online retailer delivering everything directly to the door.

Like other professional fields, retail does not exist in a world of its own. It depends on legislation and regulations governing matters such as financial transactions and cash handling, working conditions, the environment, waste and food safety. It is also affected by regulations concerning more local circumstances: geography, local development plans, and the provision of roads and parking. Finally, there is, of course, the daily task of responding to customers’ demands and expectations.

Education and training in retail


This project examines the educational backgrounds and career paths of people working in retail. Do they have the traditional background described above? Might they previously have been self-employed before moving into retail? Do they have a completely different educational background, followed by a career in that field, before choosing retail?

Many people change careers during their adult lives, and this happens in every sector: a skilled tradesperson becomes an early year's educator, or a university graduate becomes a self-employed artist. What does this look like in retail? Where do former retail employees go when they leave the sector?

More broadly, the project investigates how vocational education, academy-level education and adult education are used throughout individual working lives.

Read more about education and training in retail

Retail offers several educational routes and many different training pathways.

The most common route is to qualify as a sales assistant through a three-year vocational education and training programme, VET (EUD). EUD programmes begin with a basic course, followed by a specialised main course. Since 2014, an alternative has been the EUX programme, which combines vocational training with an upper secondary school-leaving qualification. This programme takes five years in total.

Many people also enter retail after completing upper secondary education. They can choose a shorter sales assistant training programme or begin management training. Management programmes are mainly offered through the adult vocational training system (AMU) and combine work in a shop with courses over a period of six months to a year.

After completing an EUD programme and gaining a few years of practical experience, employees can progress to a short-cycle higher education programme, either a full-time Academy Profession programme or a part-time academy programme.

Finally, those seeking a management role in particular can progress to a Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (HD) or a master’s degree, such as an MBA. Management programmes at business schools abroad are also popular.

A common feature of retail education and training is that programmes have been developed within organisations outside the traditional education system. Employers’ organisations, trade unions and professional associations are more involved than in other areas of education, such as health, science and technology, and the social sciences. This gives the programmes a distinctive character that reflects the sector’s understanding of itself.

Young employees

The project examines how young people develop their understanding of what it means ‘to work’ through jobs in retail. We also investigate what work means in practice for each person’s identity in relation to friends, family and wider society. Finally, we consider how young people see their retail jobs as a starting point for thinking about their future working lives.

Read more about young employees

Retail is a ‘young’ sector, and many employees are teenagers or young adults. Some have chosen retail as a career and are undertaking vocational training (EUD) or management training. Others do not yet know what they want to do in adult life. Either way, retail is where many people gain their first experience of the labour market.

The sector faces challenges both in attracting staff and in retaining younger employees. Research from other countries also suggests that individual workplaces can face difficulties with old-fashioned shop hierarchies and working hours. Career opportunities are not always clear either.

Research also shows that retail can be a good place to gain initial work experience: employees can learn a great deal about teamwork as well as how to stand on their own two feet. They are quickly given responsibility, which can provide a foundation for adult life.

Experienced employees


The project examines how experienced employees have become the people they are, and how social developments affect their relationship with work and colleagues. It also explores how experienced employees see their role within the workplace community and in relation to consumers, the goods sold and the other services offered by their workplace.

Read more about experienced employees

As an experienced retail employee, manager or owner, how have you become the person you are? Where do you find inspiration, and how do you know the right thing to do in different situations? In other words, what does it mean to be a ‘proper shopkeeper’?

Knowing how to do the right thing as an employee typically rests on specific knowledge of the things you work with, practical experience and an ability to see the bigger picture. How have experienced employees learnt this? For most, it will involve education or schooling, a period as an apprentice or young employee, and then several years as a recognised participant in the workplace community. Teamwork and shared goals generally help create a sense of belonging. Inspiration may come from the immediate cultural environment at work, where community, shared experiences and recognition motivate employees. Alternatively, employees may draw on other experiences, such as meeting a manager or colleague they looked up to or found inspiring in some other way.

In any workplace, teamwork and shared goals help create a sense of belonging. Inspiration can come from the workplace’s own environment, where community, shared experiences and recognition motivate the group of employees. People may also have met others, such as a manager or colleagues, whom they look up to and perhaps even admire. Or they may wish to pass on their own knowledge and insights to younger generations.

Conditions in the sector are changing, often within experienced employees’ own working lives. Retail’s role in society rests on a long history of trade and commercial activity that has been central to social development. Today, changes happen quickly, and individual employees must respond to new conditions, such as the growth of e-commerce and society’s increasing focus on sustainability. How do experienced employees understand their own ability to shape a future for retail that reflects wider social changes?

Qualifications and competences in retail


In this project, we examine the qualifications people need to work in retail today. Our initial view is that these are more complex than many people assume, and that individual employees draw on many different types of qualification. We place qualifications in a broader context and also ask what ‘work’ in retail actually means. Work is a fundamental part of the human condition; indeed, we cannot help doing it. Some of this work can be understood as ‘paid employment’, while other work is unpaid or rarely paid, such as the work of the ‘housewife’ in the home.

We also examine the differences between ‘skills’, the term typically used in English-speaking countries, and qualifications. We further distinguish between qualifications and competences, understanding competences as the ability to put qualifications into practice in a specific context within a given cultural framework and set of values, such as retail. These would appear to be largely informal in nature.

Finally, we investigate future qualification needs, particularly as shaped by customer expectations and new technology.

Read more about qualifications and competences in retail

What do people need to be able to do to work in retail? The qualifications required in the sector have changed over the years and will continue to change.

  • In 1813, an apprentice ironmonger had to be able to solve the following problems in the final apprenticeship examination:
    If 1 lispund costs 246 rigsdaler, 5 mark and 14 skilling, how much does 7/10 of a pund cost?
    If 1 gross costs 36 rigsdaler, 2 mark and 23/4 skilling, how much does 15/12 dozen cost?
    For anyone unfamiliar with a lispund, here is an explanation: 1 lispund = 16 pund = 7.94 kg. A gross is a dozen dozen. A dozen is 12 items, so 12 dozen is 12 × 12 = 144 items. Beyond this, however, people learnt to be ironmongers by working as ironmongers, grocers by working as grocers, and so on. Schooling took place in the evenings.

The things people need to be able to do change over time. Until the 1960s, completing training in a professional field was sufficient; after that, it was a matter of gaining experience. People could work their way up the hierarchy, perhaps taking a few evening courses. Gradually, however, this was no longer enough, and the need to learn new things increased.

As grocery retail moved towards the first self-service shops, staff had to learn to pre-pack goods before customers asked to buy them. As advertising became more widespread, they had to learn to paint signs and advertise. When shop bookkeeping began to use punched cards, the foundations of the EAN system were laid. This subsequently became the basis for managing purchasing, stock and pricing.

Today, most entirely manual work processes have been wholly or partly replaced by technology. Instead, employees increasingly need to respond to individual customers’ needs and handle conflicts, advise on products in relation to issues ranging from allergies to sustainability, and create a ‘shopping experience’ for customers.

The question of qualifications began to emerge in the 1960s, when education and the labour market started to be linked. Since the 1990s, all types of education, from apprenticeships to university degrees, have been described in terms of qualifications. Naturally, and fortunately, there has also been growing recognition that qualifications are about more than the subject matter taught. Many qualifications are informal, such as the ability to communicate and work with others. Not everything is learnt in the classroom or through practical work. Qualifications can also be acquired informally, for example through leisure interests or voluntary work.

The supermarket as a non-place


The project examines the supermarket as a non-place and studies how employees and customers act within it.

Read more about the supermarket as a non-place

When somewhere lacks historical and social meaning and has few connections with the surrounding community, it can be understood as a ‘non-place’. Examples include airports, motorways, chain hotels, shopping centres and supermarkets. Non-places are characterised by anonymity: people do not stay longer than necessary but pass through quickly. They are typical of cities in the modern world.

We usually associate a ‘place’ with an area that involves human relationships: we can connect our identity to it and have memories of it. Think of the ice cream kiosk visited on childhood trips to the beach, the school playground or the place where you had your first kiss. Non-places, by contrast, have no such social associations.

Supermarket employees and customers may feel that they are in a non-place. It is difficult to make contact with one another, and these spaces do not encourage relationships or even conversation. Communication mainly takes the form of instructions on signs and screens. This can make a supermarket a difficult place to work: the tone of interactions between employees is affected, and the workplace culture suffers. Many customers would rather not be there and want to leave quickly. Customers, and sometimes employees too, do not take particular care of the place or the things within it.

It is important to recognise, however, that what is a non-place for one person may be a place for another. It depends on the relationships we have, or do not have, with it.